A book that picks nothing can still “beat” the market
The line stock-pick services use most is “we have beaten the S&P 500 by so many points since launch”. That number alone says nothing about stock-picking skill. We worked through an example with our own price data. From the end of June 2022 to the start of September 2026, the S&P 500 ETF (SPY) rose 101.9% (price only, dividends excluded). Imagine a book that picks no stocks at all and moves exactly 1.5 times SPY every day: over the same period it rose 175.5% (ignoring the cost of borrowing), more than 70 points ahead of the market. A book moving 1.3 times SPY rose 144.1%, more than 40 points ahead. Yet all three have the same Sharpe ratio, 1.12: every extra point came from taking on more market risk.
In a bull market, a portfolio that leans towards growth, technology and strong-momentum stocks often swings more than the market. Look only at how far it beat the index, and the market's own rise is easily mistaken for stock-picking skill.
Five questions to ask before you subscribe
- What date does the record run to? The figures on a sales page may have stopped long ago. Ask for the complete record from launch day up to now.
- What is left once the market is removed? Ask for the portfolio's beta (how much it moves, on average, when the market moves 1%) and for the return left after taking the market out. A figure that only says how far it beat the S&P 500 is one gain minus the other, which assumes the portfolio swings exactly as much as the market; for a book like the 1.5-times one above, that subtraction counts the extra risk as skill.
- Is it the whole portfolio's return, or an average of the stocks' returns? The two can differ a lot: an average treats a stock bought late in a small position the same as one bought early in a large position. What should be compared is the whole portfolio's daily value.
- Can you get the complete dated trade record? Including the positions already sold and every partial sale along the way. For a portfolio that trims winners after they grow, nobody can recompute a single stock's return without the trade record. We recently recomputed, for our own use, a few stocks named in a third-party review: one could not be reproduced as buy-and-hold however we tried, and the gain in the review was more than twice ours. The gap most likely comes from trims, but without the trade record nobody can confirm it.
- Do a few stocks carry it? Take out the biggest contributors, or the best year or two, and see what is left.
Why take it apart this way
Four years of records and dozens of stocks look like plenty. But what a stock-pick service really sells is the part left after the market is removed, and for that part the sample is often short: statistically it is often hard to tell from luck. Track records usually stop at the most flattering step, a comparison of gains with the index. Each of the five questions takes that number apart one layer further.
How we can help
If you place trades on a stock-pick or signal service's recommendations, you can send us your account's daily returns, plus, where you have them, the market's returns over the same days and the record the service publishes. We check what is left once the market is removed, whether one or two years carry the return, and whether both halves of the record hold up, and we compare the result with what the service publishes. Any check the data does not allow is reported as not done, never counted as a pass. The report goes to you, for your own decisions only, and may not be published or used for marketing.